William Christie leads his famous Arts Florissants ensemble in a performance on September 7, 2007, at Versailles's Chapelle Royale. It was one of more than a hundred concerts held at the palace to celebrate the 20th anniversary of the Centre de Musique Baroque de Versailles.
Photo: ©BALTEL/SIPA
Going for Baroque
Louis XIV's beloved music
has never been more popular


For years, visitors from around the world poured into Versailles to admire Louis XIV's favorite palace and the geometric triumph of its gardens. At the Louvre, they saw magnificent art works and artifacts amassed by the long-reigning monarch. What this dazzling picture of past splendors did not give them, however, was a sense of the central role that music played in the court of the Sun King.
    The powerful literary tradition in France long obscured the fact that Louis XIV loved music-François Couperin even wrote "Concerts Royaux" to be played in Louis XIV's bed chamber. Yet for centuries, operas, dance music, ballets and other orchestral works by such masters of the French Baroque as Jean-Baptiste Lully, Jean-Philippe Rameau, Marc-Antoine Charpentier and Marin Marais languished in silence in the archives of the Bibliothèque Nationale. Few French music lovers who enjoyed Maurice Ravel's tribute to Baroque music, "Le Tombeau de Couperin," knew anything about Couperin-and fewer still had ever heard his music.
    Why this state of neglect? The dismissive explanations were usually that Baroque was too stiff, over-stylized, hellishly difficult to perform and-in the case of the operas-hugely expensive to mount. These arguments are not entirely without merit: 17th-century French opera productions called for elaborate scenery by master set designers such as the Galli da Babiena family, along with rich costumes, dance interludes and stage machinery for lowering the gods from the heavens (hence the phrase "deus ex-machina").
    In spite of the long odds, French Baroque has nonetheless made a comeback, not only in the broader context of recent widespread enthusiasm for classical music in general but as a welcome renascence in its own right. The gods and goddesses, the heroes and heroines, and the demons and shepherds that kept Louis XIV glued to his seat in Versailles are back onstage in elaborate opera productions, not only in France but in the United States (where many of them are being seen for the first time) and elsewhere. In addition, a stream of new recordings-where once there was a mere trickle-has made French Baroque music more accessible, widening its global audience.
    A pivotal figure in breathing new life into French Baroque music is an American musicologist, conductor and harpsichordist from Buffalo, New York: William Christie. A long-time French resident-and now a French citizen and an Officier in the Légion d'Honneur-Christie was teaching Baroque vocal repertoire at the Paris Conservatoire in 1979 when he formed a musical ensemble and named it Les Arts Florissants, after a composition by Charpentier. The group quickly became known as consummate specialists of the French operatic repertoire of the 17th and 18th centuries, with equally distinguished excursions into Italian and English works. Christie acquired a reputation in musical circles as a martinet with his musicians, but his exacting standards clearly paid off. London's The Independent has called the group's playing "unutterably chic, sensitive and vivid throughout-almost tear-provokingly perfect."
    Christie was first exposed to early French music by his mother, a choir director, who gave him music lessons. Yet he attributes his epiphany to his grandmother, who gave him a recording of Couperin's organ music. "That blew my mind-it was one of the most extraordinary things I had ever heard," he says. "Lights flashed, bells clanged, and I was in a different state." In other words, he was hooked.
    In 1982, Les Arts Florissants staged the work for which they were named at the Palace of Versailles. The performance was not only a critical success but also seduced a new audience. Major recognition came five years later with the Paris Opera's presentation of "Atys" by Lully, the man who defined French opera under Louis XIV (this particular work was the king's favorite). Christie's ambitious production of "Atys"-the first in France since 1760-established the French early music movement in the musical calendar.
    By the 1990s, Les Arts Florissants had built up an impressive repertoire of French Baroque productions, including Rameau's "Hippolyte et Aricie," his first and in many ways finest operatic work, and "Les Indes Galantes." "Hippolyte" is Rameau's re-working of "Phèdre"; "Les Indes Galantes" is more a show than an opera-a series of mini-spectacles set in faraway lands (Turkey, America) and conceived to have mind-boggling sets and costumes, not to mention very busy dance sequences.
    Whether Le Roi Soleil would recognize contemporary renditions of the operas of his day or merely find them vaguely familiar is open to question. The French Baroque movement strives for authenticity, basing productions on research of the strictures and rules that initially governed the performances. For example, the peculiarities of period diction and the delicate, quivering French Baroque trill in the signing are Arts Florissants trademarks. Still, New York Times music critic John Rockwell, who was at the "Atys" premier in 1987, described it as "not so much a period 17th-century re-creation as a 20th-century fantasy about the 17th century (just as the opera itself is a 17th-century fantasy about classical antiquity)."
    Since 1987, the main quest for authenticity has been entrusted to the Centre de Musique Baroque de Versailles, a government-funded research organization that rediscovers, restores and advances France's musical heritage of the 17th and 18th centuries.
    Aside from being the main publisher of French music scores, the Centre produces recordings, and anyone interested in a total immersion course in early French music could do worse than to acquire the Centre's 20-CD collection, "200 Ans de Musique à Versailles," released this year.
    But while authenticity is important, what matters most is that French Baroque music has made a comeback and recaptured public attention. "The challenge," commented Le Monde back in 2007, "was to prove that Baroque music was for everyone." By then, of course, that challenge had long since been successfully met. How else to explain the box office success of the 1991 film Tous le Matins du Monde-winner of seven French Césars-whose central character, Monsieur de Sainte-Colombe, was a 17th-century musician and composer so obscure that even his first name is unknown? Christie himself says, "I'll put on my epitaph that I was able to convince a number of people for a number of years that there are as many great composers, and as many masterpieces in the 17th and 18th centuries as there are in the 19th and 20th. This came as a great surprise to a lot of people."
    Early French music continues to be a modest-sized growth industry. Ensembles such as Christophe Rousset's Les Talens Lyriques in Paris and the Grenoble-based Les Musiciens du Louvre, founded in 1982 by resident director Marc Minkowski, are flourishing. Rousset, who juggles his own career as a distinguished solo harpsichodist, conducted Rameau's "Zoroastre" at the Paris Opéra-Comique in March. Outside France there is, among others, the Washington, D.C.-based Opéra Lafayette, which earlier this year staged "Le Déserteur" by Pierre-Alexandre Monsigny, a late-18th-century composer but still not too distant from the French Baroque tradition.
    But the belle of Baroque is unquestionably Emmanuelle Haim, another harpsichordist-turned-conductor of her own orchestra, Le Concert d'Astrée. This past March, the petite Parisienne with the flamboyant, ballet-like conducting style performed Rameau's "Hippolyte" in Toulouse. Haim attributes her passion for Baroque to the decade she spent working as Christie's assistant. "What he gave me above all was a love for French Baroque, especially after his Paris staging of "Atys," which proved that a Lully opera could be a living dramatic experience. After that, I knew that I wanted to devote my life to Baroque music."
    In a recent interview with BBC Music magazine, Haim said that Baroque opera-French or other-would be more widely played and therefore even more popular were it not for the additional expense of hiring a Baroque orchestra. "You cannot do Monteverdi or Rameau with a modern orchestra, but opera houses that can afford a Baroque orchestra are rare-it's an extra expense on top of the regular orchestra."
    But at least, she added, staging a French Baroque opera eliminates one major casting problem compared with Italian operas of the same period: The French never followed the widespread Italian practice of using castrati tenors-and there aren't many of them around these days.


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Best of Baroque

. LES ARTS FLORISSANTS If you missed William Christie and his ensemble (
arts-florissants.com) at Zankel Hall (Julliard School of Music) on April 3, you may catch up with them at Paris's Salle Pleyel on May 4 (sallepleyel.fr). This fall (Oct. 10 through Nov. 25), they will celebrate their 30th anniversary with a series of performances at London's Barbican Theater; the program will focus on French Baroque religious music (barbican.org.uk).

. LES TALENS LYRIQUES (lestalenslyriques.com) with conductor/harpsichordist Christophe Rousset will perform at the Cité de la Musique in Paris on May 16 (cite-musique.fr). This stylish Baroque group will also make a single appearance at the Festival d'Aix-en-Provence on July 27 (festival-aix.com).

. LE CONCERT D'ASTRÉE (leconcertdastree.fr) and its sparkling founder/conductor Emmanuelle Haim will perform in Berlin in December. Meanwhile, their most recent Virgin Records CD "Lamenti," a compilation of heart-rending moments from Baroque operas, is outstanding if not exactly cheery. The recording features the incomparable French mezzo soprano Natalie Dessay and the equally impressive soprano Joyce DiDonato as soloists.

. To whet the appetite, there's French operatic finger food on the Web. YOUTUBE, for example, has some amusing sequences from Les Arts Florissants' production of "Les Indes Gallantes."

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .



music notes

THE OTHER CARMEN
Noah Stewart and Sandra Piques Eddy star as Don José and Carmen in La Tragédie de Carmen, winner of the 1984 special Tony Award for Outstanding Achievement in Musical Theatre.
Photo: Liz Lauren
Baroque is not the only French music that is enjoying renewed interest. This season, the Chicago Opera is staging a new production of "La Tragédie de Carmen"-no, not Georges Bizet's immortal opera but the 1980s deconstructionist unraveling of the original by playwright and screenwriter Jean-Claude Carrière and two transplants: the Romanian-born avant-garde composer Marius Constant and the legendary theater director Peter Brook, formerly British, now a French citizen.
    The "makeover" (to use a trendy television word), which hasn't been performed for some years following its launch, retains only the four principals-Carmen, Don José, Escamillo and Micaëla-and two small speaking parts. It calls for a 15-member orchestra and a record player, and rearranges the music so that familiar arias are heard afresh and the famous overture becomes the finale. Stripped down to its bare essentials-raw emotion, violence, a love triangle-"La Tragédie de Carmen" becomes, according to Chicago Opera conductor Alexander Platt, "the ultimate work of music theater, with all the grandeur and essence of Carmen the opera without the spectacle and the unnecessary machinery."
    Constant added no new music, but the drama has undergone some changes. Chicago's version of "La Tragédie" is set in Civil War Spain of the late 1930s. Carmen is a chanteuse who smokes cigarettes but doesn't make them; in the original, she works in a cigarette factory. The most significant change is that Escamillo the bull fighter has become Escamillo the prize fighter, so the immortal "Toreador" song becomes more symbolic than specific.
    It's one of the peculiarities of the music of Spain that what many regard as the quintessential Spanish opera was written by a Frenchman, based on a novella by another Frenchman (Prosper Mérimée). But as Platt points out, "The Spanish element is there, although it's France looking at Spain." "La Tragédie," like the original, will be sung in French with the spoken dialogue in English; the American cast (mezzo-soprano Sandra Piques Eddy, tenor Noah Stewart and baritone Michael Todd Simpson) are taking French lessons. "La Tragédie de Carmen" will be performed at the Chicago Opera Theater on May 2, 5, 10, 13 and 15.
chicagooperatheater.org
-RF